Thursday, January 10, 2008

What is the advantage of a rear wheel drive vehicle?

So, once again the hubby and I had a discussion that neither of us really knew the answer to. We are looking at getting a new vehicle, and seeing as how we have had both front wheel and rear wheel drive cars we wanted to know what the difference was. Our favorite car that we have owned so far was a Lincoln LS. It had rear wheel drive and it seemed like it handled great, even in the bad weather. Anyway, I did some more digging (thanks Internet), and here is what I found out on wikepedia:

Rear-wheel drive (or RWD for short) is a common engine/transmission layout used in automobiles. RWD typically places the engine in the front of the vehicle, but the front mid-engine, rear mid-engine and rear engine layouts are also used.

Rear-wheel drive is used almost universally for driving motorcycles, whether by driveshaft, chain, or belt.

The vast majority of rear wheel drive vehicles use a longitudinally-mounted engine in the front of the vehicle, driving the rear wheels via a driveshaft linked via a differential between the rear axles. Some FR layout vehicles place the transmission at the rear, though most attach it to the engine at the front.

Rear wheel drive has fallen out of favor in passenger cars since the late 1980s[citation needed], due in part to higher manufacturing costs, and that front wheel drive is safer for a driver of average ability[1], and that it performs better on slippery roads.[2][3] However, some automobile brands, including Lincoln, Mercedes-Benz, BMW, Lexus, and Porsche continue to use rear wheel drive platforms. Rear wheel drive (or all-wheel drive) is still the preferred choice for high performance automobiles because very powerful front wheel drive cars tend to understeer[4], and the ability to fit a large engine in a front-wheel drive layout while maintaining good fore and aft weight distribution is limited. The limit of controllable power for a front wheel drive car is generally placed between 230 and 300 horsepower, and no engine larger than an OHV V8 has ever been fitted to a front wheel drive production car.

Advantages
Even weight distribution - The layout of a rear wheel drive car is much closer to an even fore and aft weight distribution than a front wheel drive car, as more of the engine can lie between the front and rear wheels (in the case of a mid engine layout, the entire engine), and the transmission is moved much farther back.[5]

Weight transfer during acceleration - During heavy acceleration, weight is placed on the rear, or driving wheels, which improves traction.

No torque steer[4] (unless it's an all wheel steer with an offset differential).

Steering radius - As no complicated drive shaft joints are required at the front wheels, it is possible to turn them further than would be possible using front wheel drive, resulting in a smaller steering radius for a given wheelbase.

Better handling in dry conditions - the more even weight distribution and weight transfer improve the handling of the car. The front and rear tires are placed under more even loads, which allows for more grip while cornering.[1]

Better braking - the more even weight distribution helps prevent lockup from wheels becoming unloaded under heavy braking.[1]

Towing - Rear wheel drive puts the wheels which are pulling the load closer to the point where a trailer articulates, helping steering, especially for large loads.[1]

Serviceability - Drivetrain components on a rear-wheel drive vehicle are modular and do not involve packing as many parts into as small a space as does front wheel drive, thus requiring less disassembly or specialized tools in order perform servicing.[citation needed]

Robustness - due to geometry and packaging constraints, the CV joints attached to the wheel hub have a tendency to wear out much earlier than the universal joints typically used in their rear-wheel drive counterparts. The significantly shorter drive axles on a front-wheel drive car causes the joint to flex through a much wider degree of motion, compounded by additional stress and angles of steering, while the CV joints of a rear wheel drive car regularly see angles and wear of less than half that of front wheel drive vehicles.[citation needed]

Disadvantages
Oversteer and the related problem of fishtailing.

On snow, ice and sand, rear-wheel drive loses its traction advantage to front or all-wheel drive vehicles which have greater weight on the driven wheels. Rear wheel drive cars with rear engine or mid engine configuration do not suffer from this, although fishtailing remains an issue.

Some rear engine cars (e.g. Porsche 911) can suffer from reduced steering ability under heavy acceleration, because the engine is outside the wheelbase and at the opposite end of the car from the wheels doing the steering.

Decreased interior space - In a passenger car, rear wheel drive means: Less front leg room as the transmission tunnel takes up a space between the driver and front passenger, less leg room for center rear passengers (due to the tunnel needed for the drive shaft), and sometimes less trunk space (since there is also more hardware that must be placed underneath the trunk). There are some exceptions to this as rear engine designs do not take away interior space. (See Porsche 911, and Volkswagen Beetle)

Increased weight - The components of a rear wheel drive vehicle's power train are less complex, but they are larger. The driveshaft adds weight. There is extra sheet metal to form the transmission tunnel. There is a rear axle or rear half-shafts, which are typically longer than those in a front-wheel drive car. A rear wheel drive car will weigh slightly more than a comparable front wheel drive car (but less than four wheel drive).

Improper weight distribution when loaded - A rear wheel drive car's center of gravity is shifted rearward when heavily loaded with passengers or cargo, which may cause unpredictable handling behavior.[2]

Higher initial purchase price - Probably due to more complex assembly (the powertrain is not one compact unit) and added cost of materials, rear wheel drive is typically slightly more expensive to purchase than a comparable front wheel drive vehicle. This might also be explained by production volumes, or the fact that the majority of rear-wheel cars are in the sports/performance/luxury categories. Few "family" sedans have rear-wheel drive, so a cost comparison is not necessarily possible.[citation needed]

The possibility of a slight loss in the mechanical efficiency of the drivetrain (approximately 17% coastdown losses between engine flywheel and road wheels compared to 15% for front wheel drive - these losses are highly dependent on the individual transmission, and the source should be cited). Cars with rear engine or mid engine configuration and a transverse engine layout do not suffer from this.

The long driveshaft (on front engine cars) adds to drivetrain elasticity.

Current or recent rear wheel drive cars to 2006
While the popularity of rear wheel drive has declined since the early 1980s, it is still relatively common, and has been making something of a resurgence. Here is list of current or recent rear wheel drive vehicles. See also Category:Rear wheel drive vehicles.
Nearly all two-wheel drive trucks and most sport utility vehicles are rear wheel drive.
Alfa Romeo - Alfa 8C
Aston Martin - All models
Bentley - Arnage, Azure
BMW - All models except the MINI, and all-wheel drive variants
Cadillac - All models except DTS, BLS and all-wheel drive variants
Chevrolet - Corvette, Camaro
Chrysler - 300, Crossfire
Dodge - Viper, Charger, Magnum, Challenger,Durango
Ferrari - All models
Ford - Crown Victoria, Falcon (Australia), Fairlane (Australia), Mustang, Thunderbird
GMC - All models except Acadia and four-wheel drive variants
Holden - Commodore (all models), Statesman / Caprice
Honda - S2000, NSX
Hyundai- Genesis, Genesis Coupe
Infiniti - All models except all-wheel drive variants, I30, I35 and G20
Jaguar - All except X-Type
Jeep - All models except Compass and four-wheel drive variants
Lexus - All cars except ES, RX, and all-wheel drive variants
Lincoln - Town Car, LS
Lotus - All cars except Elan M100
Maserati - All models
Mazda - MX-5 Miata, RX-7, RX-8, 929
Mercedes-Benz - All cars except A-Class, B-Class and all-wheel drive models
Mercury - Grand Marquis, Marauder
Mitsubishi - 3000GT
Morgan - All models
Nissan - 350Z, Skyline (except 4WD models),Silvia, 180SX, 200SX, 240SX, 300ZX
Pontiac - GTO, Solstice, G8, Firebird, Trans Am
Porsche - All cars except the four-wheel drive 911 Carrera 4, 911 Turbo and Cayenne
Saturn - Sky
Smart - Fortwo, Roadster
Tofaş - Şahin, Doğan, Kartal, Serçe
Toyota - Altezza, Crown, Mark X, MR2, Supra, AE86
TVR - All models
Vauxhall Omega - known as Opel Omega in continental Europe

One of the most interesting things about this article is if you look above you will see that most of the high end cars are rear wheel drive. So, there must be something positive about it. Hope someone else found this info helpful, and take it from someone who has owned both - even driving in snow with rear wheel is not much of a struggle, after all, snow is snow:)

1 comment:

Jill said...

rear wheel drive is great for sports cars and going fast and on dry pavement. the rest are better for wet pavement snow ice and etc... that's about the gist of it!